What Is The Effectiveness Of The "Textile Light" Technology Award? Third Party Organizations Open Professional Assessment

The "textile light" China Textile Industry Association's science and technology award, which has the reputation of the Nobel prize in the textile industry, has gone through over 20 years. Since the textile science and technology education foundation of 2008 awarded the award and named it, it has awarded a large number of outstanding scientific and technological achievements in the industry. According to statistics, in the past 2008-2019 years, 1469 awards for science and technology projects and 3062 awarding units were awarded, including 11500 people and 11500 special contribution awards. The bonus amount is 11 million 740 thousand yuan. The award has become an authoritative prize in the field of science and technology in the industry, and has played a great role in promoting the construction of textile power.

This year marks the end of the "13th Five-Year" development plan of China's textile industry. As the industry pays more and more attention to industry technology awards and demands for public welfare organizations, it is necessary to review and summarize the project at this time node, scientifically evaluate the implementation of the awards since the establishment of the awards, and the effect and impact on the technological progress of China's textile industry. To facilitate the project to play a greater role in the "14th Five-Year" period. Recently, the textile optical technology education foundation decided to carry out the evaluation of the "textile light" China Textile Industry Federation science and Technology Award project.

Objective evaluation of the implementation of the project

The textile science and Technology Education Foundation has been developing for more than 20 years. It has supported and promoted the development of textile science and technology, education and talents through establishing and organizing public welfare projects every year. Organizing and managing public welfare projects is an objective requirement for public organizations, especially foundations, to carry out their mission and keep their minds in mind. How to organize and manage public welfare projects is the key to see whether public welfare projects can achieve the established public welfare goals, whether they achieve the desired results and play their due role. Assessment.

Ye Zhimin, director of the textile technology education foundation, explains that assessment is an objective judgement of the effectiveness of the project, the impact of the industry and the ability of project management. It responds to the concerns of the governing bodies, fund directors, donors, project partners, winners, volunteers, and so on, and continuously enhances the credibility of the foundation. Summing up experience and lessons from project management, we can better help us improve project management and continuously improve project management capability.

It is understood that project investigation will be an important part of collecting information and feedback from all important participants in the project evaluation process, and will mainly be conducted in the form of questionnaires and interviews. The object and scope of this survey include: 2008-2019, the "textile light" Sino spinning joint technology award project, the main completion unit and the 2008-2019 "textile light" China spinning technology award, were awarded the awards, including the representatives of people, donors and experts. In order to ensure the smooth conduct of the research work, the textile optical technology education foundation encourages individuals and units responsible for the project to actively cooperate with the research. At the same time, it promises to implement the confidentiality principle for the collected information, and only serves as an important basis for drafting the project evaluation report.

Independent assessment of third party professional bodies

The evaluation should be carried out scientifically and professionally so as to enhance the credibility of the assessment. The assessment work will be carried out through the third party professional assessment agency. Ye Zhimin said that the assessment will be carried out in the ten years of science and technology award projects and the promotion of science and technology achievements. It is the first time that the foundation has invited third parties to carry out an assessment independently. The investigation will involve units and personnel involved in the project, hoping to continue to win the support and cooperation of all of them and make new contributions to the development of textile science and technology education.

The textile science and Technology Education Foundation commissioned the Ming De public welfare research center to carry out project evaluation. According to the briefing, the Ming De public welfare research center (hereinafter referred to as "Ming De") is a private non enterprise unit officially registered in the Ministry of civil affairs in November 2012, initiated by the NGO Research Institute of the school of public administration of Tsinghua University and the China Welfare Foundation for the disabled. Since its inception, Ming De has accumulated rich experience in the evaluation of business, and has formed a business system including project evaluation, training consulting and industry research. With solid foundation research, professional work team and effective work results, it has been highly recognized by the industry.

It is understood that the "textile light" China Textile Technology Award project evaluation work has been coordinated for nearly six months. Based on the evaluation criteria developed by the international economic cooperation and Development Organization Development Assistance Committee (OECD-DAC) and the "5S assessment model" based on the practice of Ming De's own development, it is designed in accordance with the "textile light". The evaluation index system of the science and technology award of the National Federation of Textile Industry Federation covers six aspects of evaluation index, namely, project strategy, design, execution, output, effect and influence, so as to comprehensively and objectively evaluate the implementation of the project since its establishment in 2008 and its effect on the technological progress of China's textile industry.

Dialogue with Wang Caixia, director of the Ming De public welfare research centre

Q: from a professional point of view, would you like to talk about the significance of evaluation work?

A: the evaluation is aimed at the technology award project that has been launched for ten years. It is a summary of the excellent experience and shortcomings of the past project. It helps the project to continue to carry out outstanding experience and improve in time, so as to better achieve the project objectives and promote the development of the textile industry. In this process, the evaluation is carried out in an independent and objective perspective of third parties, which allows all participants in the questionnaire and interview to express their feelings and suggestions fully and truly, and feel respected. At the same time, it can also promote all parties to rethink their role in the project and the significance of the project, contribute to the future development of the project, and feel that they can also play a greater value in the project. The evaluation can also help the project parties to understand and understand the project more comprehensively and even eliminate the misunderstanding or misunderstanding of the project or other participants in the past.

Q: as a professional organization, what is the goal of project evaluation?

A: project evaluation refers to a systematic and objective evaluation of public welfare projects in a certain time dimension and social resources, clear objectives, organized project design, implementation and results by means of scientific methods, usually quantitative and qualitative methods, through scientific research and analysis. As the trustee, the Ming De public research center has three purposes: to sort out and review the implementation of the technology award in the past ten years, the effects and effects, summarize the experience and shortcomings of the science and Technology Award project, put forward suggestions for improvement, and put forward feasible paths and suggestions for the future development of the science and Technology Award project.

Q: what are the specific processes of evaluation?

A: first, the evaluation organization will do a lot of desktop research on project related information, and also need to have detailed communication with the client, understand the basic situation and characteristics of the project, and further clarify the scope and object of the evaluation. Secondly, the evaluation institution will design a set of evaluation tools suitable for the project, including evaluation index, research plan, questionnaire, interview outline and so on. Thirdly, according to the research plan, we begin to carry out the assessment research and collect the required information; finally, we collate and analyze the collected information and write evaluation reports.

In the whole assessment work, the evaluation agencies will classify the participants according to their internal and external levels. The internal participants include the evaluation team of Ming De, the external experts of Ming De and the project team of the textile light foundation. The external participants are the stakeholders of the project, mainly including the executive, donor, evaluation experts, the winners and the individuals or units that have not won the project, and the relevant government departments.

The assessment work is mainly carried out by the Ming De assessment team according to the evaluation process, and the key points are Xiang Ming German external experts and the clients concerned. Among them, information collection is the most important part of the whole assessment work. It is necessary for external participants to give strong support, timely participation in questionnaires, interviews, etc. to provide complete and true information can help us form an objective and real professional assessment report, and provide feasible, professional and effective suggestions for future development of the project.

Q: what are your requirements for the evaluation process?

A: as an evaluators, all participants in the assessment work can be actively supported. At the same time, we hope that the Executive Committee of the foundation and the technology award can provide timely and complete project information needed for our work, help to communicate with the donors, beneficiaries, and other groups to carry out the necessary interviews, questionnaires and so on. Most importantly, in the whole process of the assessment work, the two sides can maintain timely and effective communication and finish work on time and quality. To help improve the development of the project. At the same time, the effective completion of the evaluation work also depends on the cooperation of all stakeholders in the questionnaire, interview and other work, providing real information and making contributions to the future development of the science and Technology Award project with an open and serious attitude.